Well I thought I'd just bring that last thing up, because after watching 30 shows from this season I can say at least half that I watched was total trash. But there are a few true gems out there. I think it's worth looking for them, rather than keep polishing the trash and hoping it will shine some day.
I have to agree you're very lucky this season, but I feel especially sorry for Kimiko who has to watch Upotte!!, Acchi Kocchi, Saki, Kimi to Boku 2. These shows are either very moe or very boring.
Chiaki does seem to have some decent shows as well, although Hiiro no Kakera... I don't think that is going to improve either.
I could easily name a few shows that unfortunately are with the 20% uncovered anime and are most likely going to be much better than the shows mentioned above. (Kimiko or Chiaki, drop me a pm if you're tired of the moe/harem shows.)
I like your idea to let the forum members make a list of 25 anime. However, before the season starts we know as much as you do. But at this point I have a fairly good idea on what's going to be worth watching. Maybe you could postpone it one week, so that we forum members with way too much time can take out the trash? :p


